The Conflict Between Lewis Strauss and Oppenheimer in Nolan's Film

In Christopher Nolan's cinematic exploration of the Manhattan Project, "Oppenheimer," audiences witness the multifaceted narrative surrounding the Trinity Test on July 16, 1945. Amidst the film's complex storytelling, a distinct tension between Lewis Strauss and J. Robert Oppenheimer stands out.


Unraveling the Animosity

So, why did Lewis Strauss resent Oppenheimer? The film reveals three primary reasons:


  1. Diverging Political Views:

  2. Strauss and Oppenheimer were poles apart in their political ideologies. Strauss, a patriotic conservative, firmly believed in the advancement of nuclear weaponry, including the H-bomb. Conversely, Oppenheimer, a liberal with indirect ties to the Communist Party, had profound disagreements over atomic bomb usage. After witnessing the devastation in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Oppenheimer championed for international transparency and research to prevent nuclear wars. In contrast, Strauss believed in the principle of mutually assured destruction, asserting the need for America to possess nuclear weapons if adversaries like the Soviets did.


  4. The Public Hearing Incident:

  5. An important scene in the film captures a heated disagreement between the two during a public hearing. Strauss advocated for the export of radioactive isotopes. Oppenheimer, not only opposed this but also publicly ridiculed Strauss, further deepening their rift.


  7. The Einstein Factor:

  8. A pivotal moment in their relationship unfolded in 1947. Strauss offered Oppenheimer a prestigious role at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton. During their interactions, underlying tensions related to their Jewish heritage were evident. A significant scene depicts Einstein appearing to snub Strauss after a conversation with Oppenheimer, which Strauss perceived as a direct affront.

The book, "No Sacrifice Too Great: The Life of Lewis L. Strauss" by Richard Pfau, further expands on their differences. It underscores how Oppenheimer's reservations about the hydrogen bomb and his call for transparency contrasted sharply with Strauss's strategies.


The Fallout and Strauss' Later Years

Strauss' attempt to tarnish Oppenheimer's reputation through an AEC removal in 1954 backfired during his Secretary of Commerce confirmation hearings. Consequently, his government tenure concluded, and he transitioned to philanthropic endeavours until his passing in 1974.

Comments

Post a Comment